Advertisement

Elon Musk had a simple answer for Democrats talking about sending him to prison: Name the crime first. Apparently, that basic requirement now needs explaining to people who should already understand how the justice system works.

During a Wednesday interview with Andrew Ross Sorkin, the Tesla CEO and X controlling owner addressed political threats, the prospect of a presidential pardon, and Texas Democrat Gene Wu’s inability to identify a specific crime when pressed.

Advertisement

The dispute over calls for Musk’s prosecution included an exchange between Wu and NewsNation host Katie Pavlich. Asked three times to identify a crime or law Musk allegedly broke, Wu did not name one. His responses included “I don’t know” and “I just read what I read,” alongside conditional arguments and accusations that Texas Gov. Greg Abbott was hiding evidence.

That is a pretty substantial hole in an argument for putting somebody behind bars. A former felony prosecutor ought to appreciate the difference between disliking someone and identifying criminal conduct.

Sorkin also raised incoming House Oversight Chairman Robert Garcia’s warning to “lawyer up” and President Trump’s suggestion of a possible pardon for Musk.

Advertisement

Musk rejected the premise that he needed one.

“I don’t need a pardon, by the way, because I haven’t committed any crimes.”

That was Musk’s assertion, and his broader response focused on the order in which a functioning justice system is supposed to operate. Identify an offense, establish the evidence, and then pursue accountability. Starting with a preferred prisoner and working backward is not a substitute.

Advertisement

Musk described Wu’s position as “prison first, crime later.” He then compared the approach to Lavrentiy Beria under Joseph Stalin, invoking the line, “If you show me the man, I’ll show you the crime.”

The comparison was pointed, but the practical objection underneath it was straightforward: Political anger does not supply a criminal charge.

Advertisement

Musk also suggested that resentment over his election spending was part of the hostility.

“They definitely have a few people grumpy about my funding in this past election.”

He followed that with the observation that drew laughter from the audience:

“Hopefully, in this country, you still need to do an actual crime before you go to prison. You know, aspirationally, that should be how it works”

Aspirationally. There is a word Americans should not need when discussing such an elementary safeguard. Equal treatment under the law means that political connections should not protect anyone from a legitimate prosecution. It also means political enemies do not get to skip the part where they identify an actual offense.

Musk closed the point with considerably less courtroom vocabulary:

“It really needs to be first crime, then prison. Not the other way around”

Advertisement