A New Privilege Fight Is Taking Shape
The Trump administration has moved to broaden how executive privilege may apply to presidential communications, according to reporting cited by the source article. Punchbowl News reported that the Department of Justice Office of Legal Counsel issued an opinion on Monday saying a president may claim executive privilege over communications with “private advisers” when those talks relate to official decision-making, involve or reflect communications with the president or direct advisers, and remain confidential. In Washington terms, that is not just a memo. It is a fresh stack of legal sandbags placed in front of the next congressional subpoena machine.
Who Counts as a Private Adviser
The memo, signed by Attorney General T. Elliot Gaiser, defines “private advisers” broadly. It says the term includes anyone the president consults outside the Executive Branch, including members of the public, state officials, or employees of other branches of the federal government. The opinion also extends protection to communications between “direct advisers” and outside advisers, as long as the covered conditions are met. That is a wide lane, and Congress is not known for enjoying wide lanes unless it is the one driving the hearing schedule.
Why House Democrats Are Watching
The practical effect, as Punchbowl News noted, could be significant. If Democrats take control of the House, the opinion could make it harder for them to obtain large amounts of communications tied to Trump, his advisers, his cabinet, or potentially Trump-linked businesses in certain situations. House Democrats have said they want to “hold Trump accountable,” including through investigations involving the president and his family’s businesses. The DOJ view does not end oversight, but it could force investigators into a tougher legal fight over what records Congress can demand and what the White House can withhold.
The Fight Is Likely Headed to Court
The source article expects Democrats and allied groups to challenge the DOJ opinion, and that is hardly a wild guess. Major separation-of-powers disputes rarely die quietly in a filing cabinet. If a lower court blocks the policy, the issue could move up through the courts and possibly reach the Supreme Court. How the justices would rule is uncertain. For now, the DOJ has planted a marker that future presidents, not just Trump, may try to use when Congress comes knocking with subpoenas and television cameras warmed up.
The Report That Started the Scramble
WE’D LOVE TO HEAR YOUR THOUGHTS! PLEASE COMMENT BELOW.
Leave a Comment