Scott Hayes, a 47-year-old Iraq War veteran, found himself in a tough situation. After being arrested for shooting a man during a protest in Newton, Massachusetts, he was released on a $5,000 bail. This incident unfolded when Caleb Gannon, sporting a pro-Palestinian pin, charged across traffic and physically attacked Hayes. Hayes had been peacefully demonstrating with American and Israeli flags when Gannon tackled him.
A Moment of Self-Defense
In the chaos that ensued, Hayes acted in self-defense and shot Gannon in the stomach. He stood firm in court, pleading not guilty to the charge of assault and battery with a dangerous weapon. The judge placed restrictions on him by ordering him to wear a GPS ankle monitor and adhere to a curfew. However, he was allowed to continue his work as a contractor.
The Legal Battle Ahead
Hayes’ defense team made requests for him to attend religious services and medical appointments—matters briefly mentioned during his court appearance. While District Attorney Marian Ryan hinted at additional charges related to constitutional rights violations leading to injury, only one charge was formally presented: assault and battery with a dangerous weapon.
The prosecution is also pursuing criminal complaints against Gannon—the man who initiated the physical confrontation—which remains pending in court’s clerk office.
The Video Evidence
This altercation wasn’t just words; it was caught on video. The footage shows Gannon aggressively confronting pro-Israel demonstrators before tackling Hayes. In an act of self-defense, while pinned down by Gannon, Hayes legally used his firearm. Afterward, he calmly set aside his weapon and called for help from bystanders while tending to Gannon’s injuries.
Public Response: Rallying Support
The case has sparked significant public interest. A GoFundMe campaign has successfully raised over $130,000 for Hayes’ legal defense fund. Many supporters—including groups like the Republican Jewish Coalition—have rallied behind Hayes. They see him as someone who defended himself against an unprovoked attack.
Concerns from Advocacy Groups
On the flip side of this coin are concerns raised by organizations such as the Anti-Defamation League New England about how quickly charges were filed before all facts were known. This raises questions about justice and fairness in high-profile cases like this one.
A Pro-Israel Advocate’s Journey
Hayes is no stranger to activism; he’s often seen at pro-Israel rallies across New England advocating for Israel’s right to exist peacefully while demanding that Hamas release hostages currently held in Gaza. As legal proceedings unfold around this case, it underscores rising tensions tied to political protests happening nationwide.
Leave a Comment